Ortley Beach Homes for Sale

55 homes for sale in Ortley Beach, New Jersey, updated live from the Monmouth Ocean Regional MLS.

Search on the map

Toms River Long Branch Jackson Brick Lakewood Freehold Howell Manalapan Manchester Asbury Park Whiting Seaside Heights

99 Coolidge Avenue, Ortley Beach, NJ 08751

Pending

$2,298,000

Single Family Residence

99 Coolidge Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd3 ba2,500

For Rent

$3,500/mo

Single Family Residence

304 6th Avenue #Weekly

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd2 ba1,900

For Rent

$9,500/mo

Single Family Residence

53 Fort Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

5 bd4 ba2,340

Pending

$1,399,999

Single Family Residence

222 3rd Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

5 bd4 ba2,496

For Rent

$4,000/mo

Single Family Residence

8 Nichols Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd2 ba1,464

For Rent

$6,000/mo

Single Family Residence

63 Fort Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

3 bd3 ba2,600

For Rent

$6,250/mo

Single Family Residence

127 Dewey Drive

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd4 ba1,845

For Rent

$8,000/mo

Single Family Residence

111 Fielder Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

6 bd3 ba1,744

$499,999

Condominium

1901 Bay Boulevard #206

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

1 bd1 ba429

Pending

$999,999

Single Family Residence

1903 Pennsylvania Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

10B 3rd Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

17 7th Avenue #REAR/SIDE

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 bd1 ba

Pending

$1,595,000

Single Family Residence

2000 Route 35

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd3 ba2,128

For Rent

$7,800/mo

Single Family Residence

101 7th Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd3 ba

For Rent

$5,775/mo

Single Family Residence

19 Diane Lane

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

5 bd2 ba2,182

For Rent

$5,300/mo

Single Family Residence

10 4th Avenue #102

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 Dune Terrace

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd2 ba2,592

For Rent

$5,900/mo

Single Family Residence

121 Dewey Drive

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2020 Baltimore Avenue #Down

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

104 5th Avenue #Up

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

10 4th Avenue #101

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

104 5th Avenue #Down

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

3 bd1 ba1,750

For Rent

$6,000/mo

Single Family Residence

446 Eisenhower Avenue #SUMMER 2026

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

1926 Ocean Avenue #1-4

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 bd2 ba900

Homes for sale in Ortley Beach, New Jersey

Looking to buy in Ortley Beach? Neuhaus Realty serves Monmouth & Ocean County from our Red Bank office, and every Ortley Beach listing here updates live from the Monmouth Ocean Regional MLS. Reach our New Jersey team at 732-946-2911.

Careers

Join the Neuhaus team

Build your real estate career with Staten Island’s #1 agency since 1969. Whether you’re a seasoned agent or just getting licensed, we’ll give you the brand, tools, and support to thrive.

The #1 name
56+ years and the most trusted brand on Staten Island open doors for you.
Earn more
Competitive commission splits and a steady pipeline of local leads.
Modern tools
A live-MLS website, AI-powered search, and marketing that wins listings.
Real support
Mentorship, training, and a family-run culture that has your back.

Apply to join Neuhaus

Tell us a little about yourself — it only takes a minute.