Ortley Beach Homes for Sale

56 homes for sale in Ortley Beach, New Jersey, updated live from the Monmouth Ocean Regional MLS.

Search on the map

Toms River Jackson Long Branch Brick Lakewood Freehold Howell Manalapan Manchester Asbury Park Whiting Seaside Heights

For Rent

$5,500/mo

Single Family Residence

2A Holiday Road

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

61 Fielder Avenue #2ND FL

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

1820 Pennsylvania Avenue #4

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

3 bd2 ba1,112

$1,299,000

Commercial

1929B Route 35

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

— bd0 ba

$1,625,000

Single Family Residence

425 8th Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd3 ba2,184

$1,699,000

Single Family Residence

3 7th Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2030 Route 35

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 bd1 ba

$3,499,000

Single Family Residence

1851 Ocean Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

5 bd4 ba2,500

PendingFor Rent

$5,500/mo

Single Family Residence

5 Fielder Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd5 ba2,292

Pending

$1,995,000

Single Family Residence

109 Eisenhower Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd4 ba2,900

$3,888,890

Single Family Residence

1611 Bay Boulevard

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

5 bd5 ba3,671

$359,000

Condominium

1681 Route 35 #29

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

1 bd1 ba405

$1,150,000

Single Family Residence

105 Albacore Drive

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

41 Dune Terrace

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

42 Dune Terrace

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

37 Dune Terrace

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 bd1 ba774

For Rent

$7,500/mo

Single Family Residence

39 Coolidge Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

30 Dune Terrace

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

3 bd3 ba

For Rent

$8,500/mo

Single Family Residence

2023 Bay Boulevard

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd3 ba

Pending

$1,999,000

Single Family Residence

1922 Bay Boulevard

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 Second Avenue #1

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

2 bd3 ba1,494

For Rent

$14,000/mo

Single Family Residence

23 Harborside Drive

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd6 ba4,591

Pending

$2,298,000

Single Family Residence

99 Coolidge Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

4 bd3 ba2,500

Pending

$1,999,999

Single Family Residence

105 Fifth Avenue

Ortley Beach NJ 08751

5 bd4 ba3,400

Homes for sale in Ortley Beach, New Jersey

Looking to buy in Ortley Beach? Neuhaus Realty serves Monmouth & Ocean County from our Red Bank office, and every Ortley Beach listing here updates live from the Monmouth Ocean Regional MLS. Reach our New Jersey team at 732-946-2911.

Careers

Join the Neuhaus team

Build your real estate career with Staten Island’s #1 agency since 1969. Whether you’re a seasoned agent or just getting licensed, we’ll give you the brand, tools, and support to thrive.

The #1 name
56+ years and the most trusted brand on Staten Island open doors for you.
Earn more
Competitive commission splits and a steady pipeline of local leads.
Modern tools
A live-MLS website, AI-powered search, and marketing that wins listings.
Real support
Mentorship, training, and a family-run culture that has your back.

Apply to join Neuhaus

Tell us a little about yourself — it only takes a minute.