• Neuhaus Realty Inc. fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act.

74 Longfellow Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301

$ 2,280,000
74 Longfellow Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301, ,

Overview

  • Updated On:
  • October 31, 2025
  • 6 Bedrooms
  • 3.5 Bathrooms
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • 5540 Size Sft
  • 1965 Year Built

Located on the border of Todt Hill and Emerson Hill, this home sits on the grounds of the ‘1973 Godfather Movie Footprint’.

You need to allow your creative juices to start to flow as you tour through this unique structure.

Originally built as a one story, 3 bedroom broadside ranch on a 10,000 sq foot lot, the need to create private living space, within the confines of the original structure lines arose.

A detailed expansion was legally accomplished by creating a second level private living area for a multi generational home

The exterior colonial style look actually masks 2 stacked ranch style structures.

The original home features 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, a large living room and large dining room as well as a comfortable kitchen and rear facing breakfast/television room overlooking the beautiful yard complete with a large inground pool patio and garden. The two car garage grants access to the main living area which also has a finished basement with an additional bath and a canning kitchenette.

The second level was constructed with vaulted ceilings to grant as much living space as possible in a private setting. You enter into a large family room with a second bedroom hidden behind the stairway off the kitchen hall. You pass a large dining room and enormous living room and a 4 piece bathroom as you find your way to the rear suite which consists of large living room, 2 walk-in closets, and a 2 room de/study/work area.

So here you have it a 6 bedroom, 4 bath, 3 kitchen, 2 dining room, 2 living room as well as a family room, full basement and a great yard for relaxation as well as a 2 car garage, spaciously laid out in this one family 2 story home on 10,000 foot of manicured property just waiting for your creative talents to take over and make it fit your own personal taste and fill your needs

Address: 74 Longfellow Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301
State/County:
Zip: 10301
Country: United States
Property Id: 1027552
Price: $ 2,280,000
Property Lot Size: 0 ft2
Bedrooms: 6
Bathrooms: 3.5
TaxAnnualAmount: 15000
BathroomsFull: 3
ListAgentKey: 20141019181350927836000000
StreetNumberNumeric: 74
ContractStatusChangeDate: 2025-07-30
ListAgentDesignation: Accredited Buyer's Representative / ABR, Certified Residential Specialist / CRS, Seniors Real Estate Specialist / SRES
ListAgentFullName: Francine Reali
InternetAddressDisplayYN: 1
OnMarketDate: 2025-07-30
BathroomsHalf: 1
InternetEntireListingDisplayYN: 1
ListOfficeKey: 20141019170640625641000000
ListAgentLastName: Reali
Cooling: Central
CumulativeDaysOnMarket: 93
TaxLot: 41
ListingAgreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
StatusChangeTimestamp: July 30, 2025 at 07:15am
ListAgentFirstName: Francine
PriceChangeTimestamp: August 29, 2025 at 04:10pm
MajorChangeType: Price Reduced
LotSizeUnits: Square Feet
DocumentsCount: 1
LotSizeSquareFeet: 10000
OwnerName: Incontro
ListingId: 2504144
YearBuilt: 1965
ListAgentURL: http://www.franreali.com
SourceSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
SourceSystemKey: 20250716175726507133000000
ArchitecturalStyle: Colonial
ListOfficeFax: 718-420-2323
StateOrProvince: NY
ListOfficeName: Safari Realty
LotFeatures: Back, Front, Side
OriginatingSystemKey: 20250716175726507133000000
PhotosCount: 51
ListOfficeURL: http://www.safarirealtyonline.com
PhotosChangeTimestamp: August 14, 2025 at 06:52pm
BuildingAreaTotal: 5540
Stories: 2
YearBuiltEffective: 2000
OriginatingSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
OriginalListPrice: 2499888
Sewer: City
ListingContractDate: 2025-07-16
StreetSuffix: Avenue
OriginatingSystemID: M00000487
LotSizeDimensions: 100x100
StreetNumber: 74
StreetName: Longfellow
Electric: 220 Volts
ModificationTimestamp: October 31, 2025 at 07:33pm
ListOfficeMlsId: o22801
MlsStatus: Active
TaxBlock: 00838
LotSizeArea: 10000
SourceSystemID: M00000487
ParcelNumber: 00838-41
ListAgentMlsId: 7821
ParkingFeatures: Off Street
Zoning: R1-1
DocumentsChangeTimestamp: 2025-07-16T18:22:11Z
Heating: Hot Water, Natural Gas
YearBuiltDetails: Approx
ConstructionMaterials: Brick
ListAgentFax: 718-420-2323
MajorChangeTimestamp: August 29, 2025 at 04:10pm
Directions: Please use GPS
FireplaceFeatures: Living Room
MLSAreaMajor: Todt Hill
DaysOnMarket: 93
GarageSpaces: 2
MLSAreaMinor: Todt Hill
BathroomsTotalDecimal: 3.5
AddressLegal_co_Section: Mid-Island
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_CofO: Yes
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_REO: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Stories2: 2
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Style2: Colonial
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Taxes2: 15000
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Tax_sp_Abated: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Lot_sp_Dim: 100x100
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Condition: Excellent
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Half_sp_Baths: 1
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Cable: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Waterview: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Cooling: Yes
Sewer_co_City3: 1
Dining_sp_Room_co_Combination: 1
Dining_sp_Room_co_Formal: 1
Electric_co_220: 1
Exterior_co_Fence: 1
Exterior_co_Garage_sp_Door_sp_Opener: 1
Heat_sp_Source_co_Gas2: 1
Heat_sp_System_co_Hot_sp_Water2: 1
Interior_co_Ceiling_sp_Fan: 1
Interior_co_Walk_hyphen_in_sp_Closet: 1
Parking_co_Off_sp_Street: 1
Kitchen_co_Eat_sp_In: 1
Living_sp_Room_co_Combination2: 1
Living_sp_Room_co_Fireplace3: 1
Main_sp_Bath_co_Full_sp_Bath: 1
Primary_sp_Bedroom_co_Private_sp_Bath: 1
Garage_sp_Location_co_Built_hyphen_in: 1
Siding_co_Brick: 1
Yard_co_Back: 1
Yard_co_Front: 1
Yard_co_Side: 1
Broker_sp_Load_co_Broker_sp_Load_sp_Edit: Office
Outdoor Details
Garage Attached
Other Features
Ceiling Fan
Fence
Garage Door Opener
Has Cooling System
Has Garage
Has Heating System
Walk-in Closet

Schedule a tour

Tue 04 Nov
Wed 05 Nov
Thu 06 Nov
Fri 07 Nov
Sat 08 Nov
Sun 09 Nov
Mon 10 Nov
Tue 11 Nov
Wed 12 Nov
Thu 13 Nov
In Person
Video Chat
Your information

Amenities and Features

Outdoor Details
Garage Attached
Other Features
Ceiling Fan
Fence
Garage Door Opener
Has Cooling System
Has Garage
Has Heating System
Walk-in Closet

Listing Office Safari Realty

Staten Island Board of Realtors

© 2024 Staten Island Multiple Listing Service. All rights reserved. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data last updated November 4, 2025

Map

Transport
Supermarkets
Schools
Restaurants
Pharmacies
Hospitals

Virtual Tour

Property Reviews

No reviews found.
You need to login in order to post a review

Similar Listings

50 Hitchcock Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10306
Residential
Pending

50 Hitchcock Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10306

$ 789,000
Charming Semi-Attached Home in Prime Richmondtown Location Nestled on a quiet, tree-lined ...
3 1.5details
46 Parker Street, Staten Island, NY 10307
Residential
Pending

46 Parker Street, Staten Island, NY 10307

$ 579,000
Why buy a townhouse when you can own this 3 bedroom semi attached home located on a quiet ...
30 Center Place, Staten Island, NY 10306
Residential
Pending

30 Center Place, Staten Island, NY 10306

$ 425,000
Welcome to this charming single-family home in the heart of New Dorp, Staten Island, an ex ...

Compare Listings