ActiveSouth Shore, Staten Island
$899,000
391 Sleight Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10307
3 beds 2 baths 1,000 sq ft
Photos
1 / 401 / 4046 days on market · Listed May 18, 2026
391 Sleight Avenue is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Staten Island history in the heart of Tottenville. Believed to have once been owned by the original Sleight Farm family, this charming, detached home sits on an oversized property and offers timeless character, warmth, and endless potential. Rich in historic charm, the home features spacious living areas, a wood-burning fireplace, classic architectural details, and a detached garage/carriage-style structure that adds to its unique appeal. This property combines old-world charm with the privacy and space today's buyers are searching for, while also offering close proximity to all shopping and transportation. A truly special home with deep roots in Staten Island's history. Contact architect for building possibility options.
391 Sleight Avenue is a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home for sale in Tottenville, on Staten Island's South Shore. It offers approximately 1,000 square feet of living space and was built in 1931. It is offered at $899,000, MLS# 2602762.
Inside, 391 Sleight Avenue features 2 stories, a partial and Unfinished basement, a fireplace, natural Gas and Steam heat and central Air cooling. The kitchen includes dishwasher, Dryer, Freezer and Microwave. Other interior highlights include ceiling Fan(s) and Fireplace. For parking, the property offers a 2-car garage and driveway and Off Street. It sits on a lot of roughly 9,240 square feet (about 0.21 acres).
Set in Tottenville, 391 Sleight Avenue enjoys the easygoing pace of Staten Island's South Shore — quieter streets, newer homes, nearby beaches, and more space and yard for your money. Annual property taxes are approximately $7,580. To tour 391 Sleight Avenue in Tottenville, contact Neuhaus Realty — Staten Island's #1 real estate agency since 1969 — to schedule a private showing.
MLS# 2602762. Listing courtesy of SI Premiere Properties. Listing information is provided by the Staten Island Multiple Listing Service, Inc.. Listing data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
| Year | Property taxes | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2027 | $7,580 | $41,400-6.1% |
| 2026 | — | $44,100-6.4% |
| 2025 | — | $47,100-1.0% |
| 2024 | — | $47,580+22.9% |
Assessment history from the NYC Department of Finance. Property tax figure from the listing; amounts may vary with exemptions and abatements.
