PendingSouth Shore, Staten Island
$999,900
500 Pompey Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10312
5 beds 3 baths 2,652 sq ft
Photos
1 / 401 / 4052 days on market · Listed April 24, 2026
Beautiful 2 Family detached high ranch on a large corner lot in the heart of Eltingville. From the moment you enter, you'll feel the pride of ownership throughout the entire home. The main unit contains an open floor plan with newly finished hardwood floors throughout. The sunken LR flows seamlessly into a FDR & spacious EIK. There are 3 large bedrooms with brand new carpeting protecting the beautiful hardwood floors underneath & a completely renovated full bathroom. From this level, you can also access a full attic for storage & a first floor large family room with sliders to the backyard & an additional half bathroom. The 1st floor side entrance leads to a large 2 bedroom apartment containing a spacious LR, EIK & full bathroom, ideal for extra income or extended family. There is a full unfinished basement with high ceilings & plenty of storage, that is perfect for transforming into additional living space. Outside, enjoy a quiet & serene backyard with Trex deck & plenty of off street parking in your driveway leading to an attached garage. A security system with front door camera & a brand new roof, installed in 2026, are some of the many extras you'll love. Close to schools, shopping & transportation, this one is a must see!!!
500 Pompey Avenue is a 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom multi-family home for sale in Eltingville, on Staten Island's South Shore. It offers approximately 2,652 square feet of living space and was built in 1970. It is offered at $999,900, MLS# 2602217.
Inside, 500 Pompey Avenue features a two layout, a full and Unfinished basement, natural Gas and Forced Air heat and central Air cooling. Other interior highlights include ceiling Fan(s). For parking, the property offers a 1-car garage and off Street. It sits on a lot of roughly 4,998 square feet (about 0.11 acres).
Set in Eltingville, 500 Pompey Avenue enjoys the easygoing pace of Staten Island's South Shore — quieter streets, newer homes, nearby beaches, and more space and yard for your money. Annual property taxes are approximately $8,754. To tour 500 Pompey Avenue in Eltingville, contact Neuhaus Realty — Staten Island's #1 real estate agency since 1969 — to schedule a private showing.
MLS# 2602217. Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Elite. Listing information is provided by the Staten Island Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Listing data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
| Year | Property taxes | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2027 | $8,754 | $62,340+6.7% |
| 2026 | — | $58,440+2.1% |
| 2025 | — | $57,240+3.5% |
| 2024 | — | $55,320+20.4% |
Assessment history from the NYC Department of Finance. Property tax figure from the listing; amounts may vary with exemptions and abatements.
