PendingNorth Shore, Staten Island
$989,900
5 Stone Street, Staten Island, NY 10304
3 beds 5 baths 3,240 sq ft
Photos
1 / 371 / 37229 days on market · Listed November 15, 2025
Step into timeless elegance with this rare two-building property tucked away in Staten Island's historic district. Reminiscent of the charm of Ozzie & Harriet — but with a modern BAM! The main residence welcomes you through a covered portico into a gracious foyer leading to a grand formal living room with a stunning fireplace and breathtaking views of the Verrazzano Bridge. An elegant formal dining room with a window seat and a custom eat-in kitchen create the perfect space for entertaining. A convenient half bath and laundry room complete this level. Upstairs, you'll find a primary suite with private bath, two additional bedrooms, and a full hall bath. The finished lower level offers a kitchen, cozy family room with direct yard access, and a heated full-car garage. A charming guest cottage on the property provides the ultimate opportunity for extended family or guests — truly two homes on one lot! This is the perfect blend of old-world character and modern comfort. Please note~Homeowner can not close till July 1st 2026
5 Stone Street is a 3-bedroom, 5-bathroom home for sale in Grymes Hill, on Staten Island's North Shore. It offers approximately 3,240 square feet of living space and was built in 1970. It is offered at $989,900, MLS# 2506525.
Inside, 5 Stone Street features 3 stories, a finished and Full basement, a fireplace, natural Gas and Hot Water heat and central Air cooling. The kitchen includes dishwasher and Refrigerator. Other interior highlights include fireplace. For parking, the property offers a 2-car garage and garage Door Opener and Off Street. It sits on a lot of roughly 9,051 square feet (about 0.21 acres).
Set in Grymes Hill, 5 Stone Street enjoys all the character of Staten Island's North Shore — historic waterfront neighborhoods, the free Staten Island Ferry to Lower Manhattan, parks, and a lively, walkable feel. Annual property taxes are approximately $8,500. To tour 5 Stone Street in Grymes Hill, contact Neuhaus Realty — Staten Island's #1 real estate agency since 1969 — to schedule a private showing.
MLS# 2506525. Listing courtesy of Safari Realty. Listing information is provided by the Staten Island Multiple Listing Service, Inc.. Listing data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
| Year | Property taxes | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2027 | $8,500 | $47,220-0.9% |
| 2026 | — | $47,640-0.1% |
| 2025 | — | $47,700+2.2% |
| 2024 | — | $46,680+11.8% |
Assessment history from the NYC Department of Finance. Property tax figure from the listing; amounts may vary with exemptions and abatements.
