• Neuhaus Realty Inc. fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act.

42 Elmhurst Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301

$ 2,485,000
42 Elmhurst Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301, ,

Overview

  • Updated On:
  • October 31, 2025
  • 5 Bedrooms
  • 3.25 Bathrooms
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • 6256 Size Sft
  • 1987 Year Built

Nestled in one of the most desirable neighborhoods of Todt Hill, this exquisite 5-bedroom, 4-bath Tudor home masterfully blends classic charm with modern sophistication. Upon arrival, you’re greeted by an impressive facade and a two-car garage.

Step into the grand entryway, where a magnificent staircase sweeps upward, creating an immediate sense of luxury. The formal living room features soaring wood-beamed ceilings, blending classic Tudor character with modern appeal. A beautiful office off the entryway provides a private and refined space for work, complete with custom built-in bookcases.

At the heart of the home, the chef’s kitchen shines with a stunning island, high-end appliances, and ample seating for casual dining. The kitchen flows into the adjacent formal dining room, perfect for entertaining. Sliding glass doors lead to a beautifully landscaped backyard oasis with a saltwater pool, ideal for outdoor gatherings or peaceful relaxation.

Set apart from the main living areas, the family den on the first floor offers a comfortable atmosphere for unwinding, featuring a gas fireplace and large windows that invite natural light.

Upstairs, the primary suite serves as a true retreat with a grand fireplace, two spacious walk-in closets, and a luxurious marble bathroom complete with a soaking tub and separate shower. Three additional bedrooms fill the second floor. The top level, accessed via a continuation of the elegant staircase, features another bedroom, a dressing room, and a den—creating an ideal second suite

Complete with a backup generator and sophisticated details throughout, this home offers both timeless elegance and modern comforts. Truly, this home has it all.

Address: 42 Elmhurst Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301
State/County:
Zip: 10301
Country: United States
Property Id: 1063949
Price: $ 2,485,000
Property Lot Size: 0 ft2
Rooms: 11
Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 3.25
TaxAnnualAmount: 14600
BathroomsThreeQuarter: 1
BathroomsFull: 2
InternetConsumerCommentYN: 1
InternetAutomatedValuationDisplayYN: 1
ListAgentKey: 20170918151702475743000000
StreetNumberNumeric: 42
ContractStatusChangeDate: 2025-10-14
ListAgentFullName: C.Michel Scibetta-Nicolo
InternetAddressDisplayYN: 1
OnMarketDate: 2025-03-17
BathroomsHalf: 1
InternetEntireListingDisplayYN: 1
ListOfficeKey: 20141019170629118700000000
ListAgentLastName: Scibetta-Nicolo
Cooling: Central
CumulativeDaysOnMarket: 211
TaxLot: 0200
ListingAgreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
StatusChangeTimestamp: October 14, 2025 at 06:12pm
ListAgentFirstName: C.Michel
PriceChangeTimestamp: July 8, 2025 at 01:50pm
MajorChangeType: Status Change
OffMarketDate: 2025-10-14
LotSizeUnits: Square Feet
LotSizeSquareFeet: 10022
OwnerName: MUSTOVOY
ListingId: 2501260
YearBuilt: 1987
SourceSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
SourceSystemKey: 20250310181954995296000000
ArchitecturalStyle: Tudor
ListOfficeFax: 718-980-9842
StateOrProvince: NY
ListOfficeName: Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
LotFeatures: Back
OriginatingSystemKey: 20250310181954995296000000
PhotosCount: 56
ContingentDate: 2025-10-09
ListOfficeURL: http://www.defalcorealty.com
PhotosChangeTimestamp: March 17, 2025 at 07:15am
BuildingAreaTotal: 6256
Stories: 3
PurchaseContractDate: 2025-10-14
YearBuiltEffective: 2022
OriginatingSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
PoolFeatures: In Ground
OriginalListPrice: 2599000
Sewer: City
ListingContractDate: 2025-03-10
StreetSuffix: Avenue
OriginatingSystemID: M00000487
LotSizeDimensions: 109x95.25
StreetNumber: 42
StreetName: Elmhurst
Electric: 220 Volts
ModificationTimestamp: October 30, 2025 at 02:18pm
ListOfficeMlsId: o06101
MlsStatus: Pending
TaxBlock: 00882
LotSizeArea: 10022
SourceSystemID: M00000487
ParcelNumber: 00882-0200
ListAgentMlsId: 16230
ParkingFeatures: Off Street, Detached
Zoning: R1-1
DocumentsChangeTimestamp: 2025-03-10T18:36:53Z
Heating: Hot Water, Natural Gas
YearBuiltDetails: Approx
ConstructionMaterials: Brick, Stone, Stucco
ListAgentFax: 718-667-8272
MajorChangeTimestamp: October 14, 2025 at 06:12pm
Directions: TODT HILL RD TO MERRICK AVE TO ELMHURST OR TODT HILL TO OCEAN TERRACE TO ELMHURST.
FireplaceFeatures: Master Bedroom
MLSAreaMajor: Todt Hill
DaysOnMarket: 211
PendingTimestamp: 2025-10-14T18:12:22Z
GarageSpaces: 2
MLSAreaMinor: Todt Hill
AttributionContact: 718-987-7900
BathroomsTotalDecimal: 3.25
AddressLegal_co_Section: Mid-Island
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_CofO: Yes
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_REO: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Stories2: 3
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Style2: Tudor
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Taxes2: 14600
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Tax_sp_Abated: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Lot_sp_Dim: 109x95.25
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Irregular: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Condition: Excellent
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_34_sp_Baths: 1
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Half_sp_Baths: 1
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Cable: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Waterview: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Cooling: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Fireplace: Yes
Sewer_co_City3: 1
Appliances_co_Dishwasher: 1
Appliances_co_Dryer: 1
Appliances_co_Refrigerator: 1
Appliances_co_Washer: 1
Dining_sp_Room_co_Formal: 1
Dining_sp_Room_co_Separate: 1
Electric_co_220: 1
Exterior_co_Garage_sp_Door_sp_Opener: 1
Exterior_co_Sprinkler_sp_System: 1
Heat_sp_Source_co_Gas2: 1
Heat_sp_System_co_Hot_sp_Water2: 1
Interior_co_Fireplace5: 1
Interior_co_Walk_hyphen_in_sp_Closet: 1
Parking_co_Off_sp_Street: 1
Kitchen_co_Eat_sp_In: 1
Living_sp_Room_co_Formal2: 1
Main_sp_Bath_co_Full_sp_Bath: 1
Primary_sp_Bedroom_co_Dressing_sp_Room: 1
Primary_sp_Bedroom_co_Fireplace4: 1
Primary_sp_Bedroom_co_Private_sp_Bath: 1
Primary_sp_Bedroom_co_Suite: 1
Garage_sp_Location_co_Detached: 1
Siding_co_Brick: 1
Siding_co_Stone: 1
Siding_co_Stucco: 1
Yard_co_Back: 1
Pool_co_In_sp_Ground: 1
Broker_sp_Load_co_Broker_sp_Load_sp_Edit: Company
Other Features
Dishwasher
Dryer
Fireplace
Garage Door Opener
Has Cooling System
Has Fireplace
Has Garage
Has Heating System
Refrigerator
Sprinkler System
Walk-in Closet
Walk-In Closet(s)
Washer

Schedule a tour

Fri 14 Nov
Sat 15 Nov
Sun 16 Nov
Mon 17 Nov
Tue 18 Nov
Wed 19 Nov
Thu 20 Nov
Fri 21 Nov
Sat 22 Nov
Sun 23 Nov
In Person
Video Chat
Your information

Amenities and Features

Other Features
Dishwasher
Dryer
Fireplace
Garage Door Opener
Has Cooling System
Has Fireplace
Has Garage
Has Heating System
Refrigerator
Sprinkler System
Walk-in Closet
Walk-In Closet(s)
Washer

Listing Office Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.

Staten Island Board of Realtors

© 2024 Staten Island Multiple Listing Service. All rights reserved. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data last updated November 14, 2025

Map

Transport
Supermarkets
Schools
Restaurants
Pharmacies
Hospitals

Virtual Tour

Property Reviews

No reviews found.
You need to login in order to post a review

Similar Listings

117 Gary Place, Staten Island, NY 10314
Residential
Pending

117 Gary Place, Staten Island, NY 10314

$ 848,000
Welcome to this exceptional Hi-Ranch style single-family detached home in the heart of Bul ...
4 3.5details
51 Cromwell Circle, Staten Island, NY 10304
Residential
Active

51 Cromwell Circle, Staten Island, NY 10304

$ 2,095,000
When a Vision Becomes Reality... Set on a spectacular 18,000+ square foot corner lot in th ...
443 Edinboro Road, Staten Island, NY 10306
Residential
Active

443 Edinboro Road, Staten Island, NY 10306

$ 999,400
1 family Cape nestled in the prestigious Lighthouse Hill neighborhood of Staten Island. 1s ...

Compare Listings