• Neuhaus Realty Inc. fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act.

Active

1686 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10302

$ 4,250,000
1686 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10302, ,

Overview

  • Updated On:
  • December 2, 2025
  • 0 Bathrooms
  • 5978 Size Sft
  • 1932 Year Built

PRIME FOREST AVENUE COMMERCIAL OPPORTUNITY — THIS WON’T LAST!
An investment like this rarely becomes available—especially in such a coveted, high-exposure location. Situated directly on bustling Forest Avenue, just moments from the expressway and multiple major transit options, this meticulously cared-for five-unit commercial property offers exceptional visibility, consistent foot traffic, and unbeatable convenience.
Set on an oversized lot, the building boasts ample on-site parking and a clean, maintenance-free exterior that enhances curb appeal and reduces operational costs. Long-standing, stable tenants occupy all five units, offering a strong and reliable income stream from day one. This is truly a turn-key investment for the savvy buyer looking to establish long-term equity and passive cash flow.
Forest Avenue is one of the most heavily traveled commercial corridors in the region, making this location a standout for both tenants and future appreciation. Whether you’re planning for early retirement, diversifying your portfolio, or securing a prime income-producing asset, this property delivers across the board.
Location, location, location—this one truly cannot be beat. Please inquire within for financials and cap rate. Act fast—properties of this caliber and in this corridor are extremely rare and highly sought after.

Address: 1686 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10302
State/County:
Zip: 10302
Country: United States
Property Id: 1022127
Price: $ 4,250,000
Property Lot Size: 0 ft2
TaxAnnualAmount: 49632
InternetConsumerCommentYN: 1
InternetAutomatedValuationDisplayYN: 1
ListAgentKey: 20190821213207349725000000
StreetNumberNumeric: 1686
ContractStatusChangeDate: 2025-07-18
ListAgentFullName: Andrew S Porazzo
InternetAddressDisplayYN: 1
NumberOfBuildings: 1
OnMarketDate: 2025-07-18
InternetEntireListingDisplayYN: 1
ListOfficeKey: 20141019170629118700000000
ListAgentLastName: Porazzo
Cooling: Units
CumulativeDaysOnMarket: 137
TaxLot: 51
ListingAgreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
StatusChangeTimestamp: July 18, 2025 at 04:41pm
ListAgentFirstName: Andrew
PriceChangeTimestamp: December 2, 2025 at 09:28pm
MajorChangeType: Price Reduced
LotSizeUnits: Square Feet
DocumentsCount: 1
LotSizeSquareFeet: 13784
OwnerName: AB4REST Properties LLC
ListingId: 2504188
YearBuilt: 1932
SourceSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
SourceSystemKey: 20250718154917559953000000
ListOfficeFax: 718-980-9842
StateOrProvince: NY
ListOfficeName: Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
OriginatingSystemKey: 20250718154917559953000000
PhotosCount: 17
ShowingInstructions: Call Agent
ListOfficeURL: http://www.defalcorealty.com
PhotosChangeTimestamp: July 18, 2025 at 06:14pm
BuildingAreaTotal: 5978
OriginatingSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
OriginalListPrice: 4888000
Sewer: City
ListingContractDate: 2025-07-18
StreetSuffix: Avenue
OriginatingSystemID: M00000487
LotSizeDimensions: 179 x 172
StreetNumber: 1686
StreetName: Forest
Electric: 220 Volts
ModificationTimestamp: December 2, 2025 at 09:28pm
ListOfficeMlsId: o06101
MlsStatus: Active
TaxBlock: 01476
LotSizeArea: 13784
SourceSystemID: M00000487
LeasableArea: 5978
ParcelNumber: 01476-51
ListAgentMlsId: 17474
Zoning: R3-2
DocumentsChangeTimestamp: 2025-07-18T16:41:45Z
Heating: Steam, Natural Gas
YearBuiltDetails: Approx
ConstructionMaterials: Frame
ListAgentFax: 718-980-0290
MajorChangeTimestamp: December 2, 2025 at 09:28pm
ListAgentMiddleName: S
Directions: Follow GPS
MLSAreaMajor: Westerleigh
DaysOnMarket: 137
ParkingTotal: 20
StoriesTotal: 1
MLSAreaMinor: Westerleigh
AttributionContact: 718-987-7900
AddressLegal_co_Section: North Shore
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_SaleLease: Sale
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_CofO: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Stories2: 1
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Taxes2: 49632
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Tax_sp_Abated: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Lot_sp_Dim: 179 x 172
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Irregular: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Condition: Excellent
Sewer_co_City3: 1
Electric_sp_Meters_co_Individual: 1
Gas_sp_Meters_co_Individual2: 1
Electric_co_220: 1
Showing_sp_Instructions_co_Call_sp_Agent: 1
Heat_sp_Source_co_Gas2: 1
Features_co_Retail: 1
Features_co_Shopping_sp_Center: 1
Heat_sp_System_co_Steam: 1
Building_sp_Info_co_Sprinklers: No
Construction_co_Frame: 1
Parking_co_Assigned: 1
Parking_co_Off_sp_Street: 1
Garage_sp_Location_co_None4: 1
Broker_sp_Load_co_Broker_sp_Load_sp_Edit: Company
Documents_co_Property_sp_Owner_sp_Information: 1
Other Features
Has Cooling System
Has Heating System

Schedule a tour

Wed 10 Dec
Thu 11 Dec
Fri 12 Dec
Sat 13 Dec
Sun 14 Dec
Mon 15 Dec
Tue 16 Dec
Wed 17 Dec
Thu 18 Dec
Fri 19 Dec
In Person
Video Chat
Your information

Amenities and Features

Other Features
Has Cooling System
Has Heating System

Listing Office Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.

Staten Island Board of Realtors

© 2024 Staten Island Multiple Listing Service. All rights reserved. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data last updated December 10, 2025

Map

Transport
Supermarkets
Schools
Restaurants
Pharmacies
Hospitals

Property Reviews

No reviews found.
You need to login in order to post a review

Similar Listings

100 Canal Street, Staten Island, NY 10304
Commercial Sale
Active

100 Canal Street, Staten Island, NY 10304

$ 995,000
Great opportunity! Own this fully renovated commercial building with high ceilings, New HV ...
1235 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305
Commercial Sale
Pending

1235 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305

$ 699,999
Presenting a premium 2,000 SF mixed-use building on Bay Street, just off Hylan Boulevard a ...
1256 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305
Commercial Sale
Active

1256 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305

$ 1,769,999
Located along Staten Islands '' Bay Street Corridor'' the proximity to Brooklyn and NYC is ...

Compare Listings