Welcome to 140 Craig Avenue, a custom-built, all-brick Center Hall Colonial perfectly situated on a prime corner lot in the heart of Tottenville. Built by the current owners in 2008, this one-of-a-kind residence offers over 5,000 square feet of total living space, including a fully finished basement, all on a 57′ x 117′ lot — blending timeless craftsmanship with modern luxury.
Step inside and be greeted by soaring 10-foot ceilings and radiant heat throughout the entire home, including beneath the elegant tile flooring. The heart of the home is the chef’s kitchen, thoughtfully designed with a Wolf stove, Sub-Zero refrigerator, double oven, and a massive custom-built quartz dining table (130” x 65”) that remains with the home — truly an entertainer’s dream.
This home offers four oversized bedrooms, each with its own private en-suite bathroom, ensuring comfort and privacy for all. The fully finished basement adds an additional 2,000 sq. ft. of versatile space, complete with a bar, radiant heating, and two wall-unit air conditioners, making it the perfect spot for a recreation area, home gym, or guest suite.
Outdoors, enjoy your private retreat with a saltwater inground pool, professionally landscaped grounds, and a one-car garage with additional driveway parking. Premium features include Pella windows with roll-up screens, a newer hot water heater, and a 4-zone central air conditioning system for year-round comfort and efficiency.
Perfectly located in Tottenville, this home is just minutes from South Shore Commons, schools, parks, shopping, and public transportation. A rare offering, combining size, quality, and location — 140 Craig Avenue is a home you won’t want to miss.
Property Id : 1058121
Price: $ 1,899,000
Property Lot Size: 0 ft2
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 3.75
TaxAnnualAmount: 9195
BathroomsThreeQuarter: 3
BathroomsFull: 1
InternetAutomatedValuationDisplayYN: 1
ListAgentKey: 20170621173328596883000000
StreetNumberNumeric: 140
ContractStatusChangeDate: 2025-09-29
ListAgentFullName: Ariana DiMattina
InternetAddressDisplayYN: 1
ListAgentMobilePhone: 917-743-3497
OnMarketDate: 2025-09-29
BathroomsHalf: 1
InternetEntireListingDisplayYN: 1
ListOfficeKey: 20141019170629118700000000
ListAgentLastName: DiMattina
Cooling: Central
CumulativeDaysOnMarket: 7
TaxLot: 0069
ListingAgreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
StatusChangeTimestamp: September 29, 2025 at 02:06pm
ListAgentFirstName: Ariana
MajorChangeType: New Listing
LotSizeUnits: Square Feet
DocumentsCount: 0
LotSizeSquareFeet: 6384
OwnerName: AGOSTINO
ListAgentOfficePhone: 718-987-7900
ListingId: 2505739
YearBuilt: 2006
ListAgentURL: http://DEFALCOREALTY.COM
ListAgentPreferredPhone: 917-743-3497
SourceSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
SourceSystemKey: 20250929134537710924000000
ArchitecturalStyle: Colonial
ListOfficeFax: 718-980-9842
StateOrProvince: NY
ListOfficeName: Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
LotFeatures: Back
OriginatingSystemKey: 20250929134537710924000000
VideosCount: 1
PhotosCount: 46
ListOfficeURL: http://www.defalcorealty.com
ListAgentStateLicense: 10401304110
PhotosChangeTimestamp: September 29, 2025 at 02:17pm
BuildingAreaTotal: 4000
Stories: 2
YearBuiltEffective: 2006
OriginatingSystemName: Staten Island Multiple Listing Service
PoolFeatures: In Ground
OriginalListPrice: 1899000
Sewer: City
ListingContractDate: 2025-09-29
StreetSuffix: Avenue
OriginatingSystemID: M00000487
LotSizeDimensions: 56 X 114
StreetNumber: 140
StreetName: Craig
Electric: 220 Volts
ListAgentEmail: dimattinaariana@gmail.com
ModificationTimestamp: October 6, 2025 at 06:32am
ListOfficeMlsId: o06101
MlsStatus: Active
VideosChangeTimestamp: 1970-01-01T00:00:00Z
TaxBlock: 08041
LotSizeArea: 6384
SourceSystemID: M00000487
ParcelNumber: 08041-0069
ListOfficeEmail: mikeg@defalcorealty.com
ListAgentMlsId: 16249
ParkingFeatures: Assigned
Zoning: R3X
DocumentsChangeTimestamp: 2025-09-29T14:06:36Z
Heating: Hot Water, Natural Gas
YearBuiltDetails: Approx
ConstructionMaterials: Brick
ListAgentFax: 718-980-9842
MajorChangeTimestamp: September 29, 2025 at 02:06pm
Directions: PLEASE USE GPS FOR DIRECTIONS
MLSAreaMajor: Tottenville
DaysOnMarket: 7
GarageSpaces: 1
MLSAreaMinor: Tottenville
BathroomsTotalDecimal: 3.75
AddressLegal_co_Section: South Shore
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_CofO: Yes
ContractLocation_sp_Information_co_REO: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Stories2: 2
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Style2: Colonial
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Taxes2: 9195
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Tax_sp_Abated: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Lot_sp_Dim: 56 X 114
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Condition: Excellent
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_34_sp_Baths: 3
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Half_sp_Baths: 1
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Cable: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Waterview: No
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Cooling: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_Fireplace: Yes
General_sp_Property_sp_Info_co_HOA_sp_YN: No
Sewer_co_City3: 1
Appliances_co_Dishwasher: 1
Appliances_co_Dryer: 1
Appliances_co_Microwave: 1
Appliances_co_Refrigerator: 1
Appliances_co_Washer: 1
Dining_sp_Room_co_Combination: 1
Electric_co_220: 1
Exterior_co_Garage_sp_Door_sp_Opener: 1
Heat_sp_Source_co_Gas2: 1
Heat_sp_System_co_Hot_sp_Water2: 1
Interior_co_Ceiling_sp_Fan: 1
Interior_co_Fireplace5: 1
Interior_co_Humidifier: 1
Interior_co_Walk_hyphen_in_sp_Closet: 1
Interior_co_Wet_sp_Bar: 1
Parking_co_Assigned: 1
Kitchen_co_Eat_sp_In: 1
Kitchen_co_YardDeck_sp_Access: 1
Living_sp_Room_co_Combination2: 1
Main_sp_Bath_co_Full_sp_Bath: 1
Garage_sp_Location_co_Built_hyphen_in: 1
Siding_co_Brick: 1
Yard_co_Back: 1
Pool_co_In_sp_Ground: 1